In 1960 Troop 64 established the "Scout of the Year" award in memory of Bill Coyne, long serving Scoutmaster of the Troop.
Up to three scouts per year may be recognized for their Scout Spirit, leadership, participation and personal advancement.
Scouts receive the award only once. An engraved BSA medal and wall plaque is awarded and their name is placed on this honor roll.
| 1960 - Greg Meredith | 1972 - James Ulle | 2000 - Kyle Roebuck |
| 1960 - David Hylinski | 1973 - Randy Thomas | 2001 - Andrew Brown |
| 1960 - Andrew Novak Jr. | 1973 - Alan Stover | 2002 - James Ulle, Jr. |
| 1961 - Dennis Dingley | 1974 - Frank Vaccariello | 2003 - Matthew Ulle |
| 1961 - Martin Hosta | 1974 - Davif Haught | 2003 - Max Johnson |
| 1961 - Robert Sopko | 1974 - Todd Thomas | 2004 - John Shook |
| 1962 - William McManus, Jr. | 1975 - Brian Scneider | 2005 - Tim Corlett |
| 1962 - Martin Feeney | 1975 - Paul Crouser | 2005 - Mark Clavin |
| 1962 - Edward Kinkelaar, Jr. | 1976 - Ronald Nyegar | 2006 - Cory Austin |
| 1963 - Jon Davis | 1976 - Tony Vaccariello | 2006 - E. Benjamin Ulle |
| 1963 - Thomas Murphy | 1977 - Michael Vaccariello | 2007 - John E. Ulle |
| 1963 - Michael Cicconetti | 1977 - Michael Beres | 2007 - Daniel Lenz |
| 1964 - Keith Barrish | 1978 - Michael Serdio | 2008 - Thomas Emelko |
| 1964 - Mike Evangelista | 1978 - William Paugh | 2008 - Jason Spivak |
| 1964 - Kevin McManus | 1979 - George Thomas | 2010 - Andrew Ferrell |
| 1965 - Richard Horvath | 1979 - Thomas Unterwagner | 2010 - Joseph Royer |
| 1965 - John Kish | 1980 - Mark Johnson | 2012 - Cody Thompson |
| 1965 - Robert Martin | 1980 - Michael Caplinger | 2016 - Zak Smith |
| 1966 - Charles Emming | 1981 - Thomas Rossley | 2017 - Michael Petti |
| 1966 - Joseph Shoop | 1982 - Donald Abrahamson | 2018 - Charlie Nunes |
| 1966 - E. Charles Ulle | 1983 - Kenneth Brown | 2019 - Ryan Grabnar |
| 1967 - Charles Robinson | 1984 - James Koeth | 2019 - Raymond Hoon |
| 1967 - Nicolas Nenno | 1985 - Matt Sabo | 2019 - Damian Rutti |
| 1967 - William Whipple | 1986 - Steve Toth | 2020 - Sam Watkins |
| 1968 - William Coyne | 1986 - John Higgins | 2020 - Jack Cuff |
| 1968 - Robert Kropac | 1987 - Keith Varga | 2022 - Evan Filson |
| 1968 - Michael Pandy | 1988 - Kenneth Bair | |
| 1969 - Michael Kinkelaar | 1989 - Arthur Shiner, Jr. | |
| 1969 - Franklin Ulle | 1990 - Mike LaRusch | |
| 1969 - Terrence McManus | 1991 - Andy Shiner | |
| 1969 - Gilbert Bonscer | 1992 - J.P. Letki | |
| 1970 - Steven Kerestman | 1993 - Joe Kneier | |
| 1970 - Gregory Caple | 1994 - Matt Urbaniak | |
| 1971 - Jeffrey Powers | 1995 - Tim Reilly | |
| 1971 - Michael Rogan | 1996 - John LaTeulere III | |
| 1971 - Kevin McDaniel | 1997 - Adam LaSota | |
| 1972 - Jon Nelson | 1998- John Picciano | |
| 1972 - Michael Markiewich | 1999 - Brian Myers |